Skip to content
Dr. Ali Al-Mur Encyclopedia
All Articles
Export Considerations by Dr. Ali Al-Mur

Approaches to Nuclear Energy

Published:
February 21, 2010
Reading time:
4 min read
Category:
Essay

Episode 2, "Export Considerations", examines the idea of exporting nuclear energy.

Published in Jordan's Al-Sabeel newspaper on 21 February 2010.

When we finish building nuclear power plants with a capacity of at least 3,000–4,000 megawatts (as announced), the national electricity grid will be able to absorb less than 400–800 megawatts of nuclear electricity, that is, less than one third of the capacity of the nuclear plants we will have built! This means that we will need to export at least 2,200–2,600 megawatts. That would require concluding long-term contracts with a group of countries, contracts that cannot be breached or cancelled for any reason, to ensure that those countries do not stop importing such a large amount of energy from us.

Stopping imports for any reason (for example, because those countries wish to own energy sources of their own) would mean that the nuclear power plants we build, which will have cost tens of billions of dinars, would stop operating, or at the very least lose their economic viability because of a drop in their availability factor, which must not fall below 90% for a nuclear plant to be economically viable. A drop of just 1% in the availability factor would cause a loss of 10–20 million dinars every year for a single nuclear plant in the size range mentioned. So what would happen with a large number of plants (availability problems increase with the number and size of plants)? What would the cumulative effect of low availability be on the viability of a huge project of 4,000 megawatts or more, when it is built on a hypothetical factor such as export? And what would the consequences of the losses be for a nuclear programme that is considered critical even by the standards of large, wealthy countries that are self-sufficient in the supporting fields, which cover every sector of economic and social development?

To illustrate, if we take just one of the many sectoral variables that affect the decision on the nuclear option, namely the capacity of the national grid, we find that two conditions must be met for the export assumption to come closer to being valid.

First, the grid must be able to absorb the margin of imbalance in the energy balance. This condition is far out of reach given the grid's limited capacity compared with the targeted capacity (4,000 megawatts), because nuclear power plants are used to meet only 10–20% of the base load, so that the grid remains stable and the reactors are not subjected to forced shutdowns, which in turn expose nuclear plants to the risk of accidents.

Second, the selling price of the product (the unit of electricity) must be lower than its production cost in the countries importing energy from us. This assumption is incorrect, because we cannot compete with countries such as Egypt and Syria, which produce energy more cheaply because they possess cheap primary energy sources, such as gas, among other reasons!

It is therefore clear that the desire to implement this astronomical project on an unguaranteed justification, or an unrealised assumption, namely "export", may turn it (as much as it is a beautiful dream that plays on our imagination) into an exhausting nightmare that drains our resources and becomes a heavy burden at every level; and that is assuming, to begin with, that it can be implemented at all! Which it cannot!