Skip to content
Dr. Ali Al-Mur Encyclopedia
All Articles
Objectives and Goals Considerations by Dr. Ali Al-Mur

Approaches to Nuclear Energy

Published:
March 15, 2010
Reading time:
5 min read
Category:
Essay

Episode 5, "Objectives and Goals Considerations", examines the project's purposes and objectives and how realistic they are.

Published in Jordan's Al-Sabeel newspaper on 15 March 2010.

Under certain conditions, nuclear energy has proven its economic viability for generating electricity. Today there are 443 nuclear reactors in 30 countries around the world, producing 15% of the world's electricity. However, nuclear energy's own record in water desalination is very weak: today there is not a single nuclear plant used for desalination on a commercial basis, and this file is almost completely closed after occupying a large share of countries' attention since the early 1960s. The following is a summary of international experience in this field:

  1. In 1972, the former Soviet Union built a dual-purpose plant (for electricity generation and water desalination) with a capacity of 1,000 thermal megawatts. The plant continued to operate at 520 thermal megawatts, generating 90 megawatts of electricity and 65,000 cubic metres of water per day, until 2003, when it was closed!
  2. Japan installed desalination lines at some of its nuclear plants with a capacity of 15,000 cubic metres of water per day, but interest in them later waned.
  3. China drew up designs for small reactors of 10–200 thermal megawatts to supply coastal areas and small islands with electricity and with water desalinated by multi-effect distillation, at a capacity of 8,000–150,000 cubic metres per day. These designs have been tested in practice only on a very small reactor with a capacity of 5 thermal megawatts.
  4. South Korea drew up designs for a nuclear desalination plant linking a 330-thermal-megawatt pressurised light-water reactor to produce 40,000 cubic metres of water per day, with the rest used to produce electricity. The model was not adopted more widely.
  5. In 1972, a feasibility study was prepared in Jordan for generating electricity and desalinating water from the Gulf of Aqaba, and it did not prove feasible.
  6. In 1989, five Arab countries (Egypt, Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia and Libya) launched an initiative to prepare a feasibility study for an Arab-African project to produce water using nuclear energy (the author took part in its meetings). The project was halted several years later.

From the above, the following becomes clear:

  1. Technically, "nuclear desalination" has not yet moved beyond the experimental stage and has not caught on at a commercial scale. Even in the Soviet experience, which is considered the largest, the nuclear reactor operated for a full 32 years at a thermal efficiency of only 52% and an overall efficiency of only 11%.
  2. If we set aside the technical aspect and turn to security considerations, we find that matters are not well either; indeed, they are even more critical in light of the particularities of the project, the region and the country (in terms of limited resources and the lack of accumulated experience).
  3. Experience has shown that the more purposes nuclear facilities serve, in addition to their size, the more complex their operations become. Control over general safety requirements consequently weakens and their quality declines; the likelihood of accidents and forced-shutdown problems increases; and so do the costs of upkeep, maintenance and operation, casting dark shadows of doubt over the project's viability, which is fragile in the first place, as we have shown elsewhere.
  4. If we set aside the technical and security aspects and examine the economic aspect, a dual-purpose project is not necessarily economically viable, for reasons related to the particularities of nuclear energy that I discussed on a previous occasion, and to the particularities of the site, the "Aqaba area". I was once seconded to work at a conventional dual-purpose steam plant, and most of the engineers' time was spent attending to the pumps and cleaning the water pipes of marine organisms. Because of this, the plant stopped frequently, leaving it with a very low availability factor, which affected its economics until it was shut down. Moreover, that plant was only tens of metres from the sea, unlike our hoped-for plant, which will be tens of kilometres away, making the conveyance of water technically more difficult and very costly because of the distance, as we will see in the next episode.
  5. If we set aside all these technical, security and economic aspects and consider the type of product and the relationship with investors, we find many questions that must be answered before we even think of resorting to the option of nuclear desalination, such as:
    • Would a small country like Jordan risk using its first precious, cherished (pampered) nuclear plant to test this option, ahead of all the world's countries, or on behalf of the manufacturing companies?
    • If that were possible (and we do not lack wisdom or expertise), would investors be encouraged to take up this option?
    • If some were encouraged, to what extent would the owners of capital be interested in producing water and selling it at reasonable, market-based prices, if the work were to be carried out on a purely commercial basis?
    • If some were interested, could we delegate control over this product to others (investors), knowing that water is one of the most essential commodities for human beings and cannot be subject to purely investment-driven calculations?

In short, this option (the dual-purpose nuclear plant) involves great and very costly risks, and it needs to be reconsidered on scientific and practical grounds, away from passing ideas or purely academic convictions.