Skip to content
Dr. Ali Al-Mur Encyclopedia
All Articles
Profit and Loss Considerations by Dr. Ali Al-Mur

Approaches to Nuclear Energy

Published:
March 2, 2010
Reading time:
7 min read
Category:
Essay

Episode 3, "Profit and Loss Considerations", examines the feasibility of the announced project and claims that it would generate hundreds of millions of dinars in profits.

Published in Jordan's Al-Sabeel newspaper on 2 March 2010.

There is no doubt that the larger a nuclear project is, the greater the risk, and the greater the costs that must be paid to deal with it at every stage: design, construction, operation and decommissioning (an increase that is multiplicative rather than proportional, especially for large projects). It is a cumulative, aggregating issue. Its impact expands in space to cover the whole world, starting with what is nearest and moving outwards (the site, the country, the region, the wider area and the world), and extends in time to affect present and future generations for thousands of years. The relevant international bodies have therefore adopted strict standards that protect not only the people who live alongside the project in its own time, but also neighbouring areas and future generations, even for thousands of years!

This does not mean that we should refrain from, or hesitate to, benefit from nuclear energy. But everything has its price! A state (any state) must commit to these strict international standards and bear the costs of protecting people and preserving the environment from the dangers of radiation, now and in the distant future, at the site, near it and far from it, and only then consider whether the project is economically viable or not.

These considerations lead us to pause at some of the "particularities" that affect the viability of nuclear projects, which involve hundreds of strongly interrelated and highly volatile variables that grow in variety and intensity as the nuclear project grows in size.

The feasibility calculations of a nuclear project are not limited to the direct costs we pay for consultancy, engineering designs, materials, and the facilities and equipment the project needs, or for meeting the requirements of radiation protection and nuclear safety and security. They go beyond these to other costs that must be borne to guard against foreseen and unforeseen hazards and risks over the project's design life and for thousands of years afterwards. These may arise from the following main factors:

  1. Nuclear accidents: These can be devastating and may occur inside or outside the facility, even anywhere in the world, with the resulting local, regional and international obligations falling on the state on whose territory, and under whose jurisdiction, the project is built.
  2. Radioactive releases under normal operating conditions: These often have a wide geographical and regional reach, affecting every element of the environment, people and property, with the resulting international obligations, material and moral, which are usually large and costly.
  3. Radioactive waste: This continues to generate radiation and heat for thousands of years. A large nuclear programme producing, for example, 4,000 megawatts generates around 1,000 tonnes of gaseous, liquid and solid radioactive waste every year. This waste must be stored temporarily, then treated, then disposed of permanently in permanent repositories under strict control, because it remains liable to explode at any moment due to the large amounts of heat generated in it (even when it is encapsulated and buried underground). It is also liable to pollute the environment and water sources and to harm people, and it may have costly regional consequences.
  4. Security precautions: In the case of nuclear power plants, these are not limited to the day or night guard shifts usually provided by private security companies at non-nuclear plants and facilities, which a few unarmed people can carry out. For large nuclear projects they require military bases equipped with every necessary weapon, even missile platforms and aircraft, armed patrols, and continuous, strict surveillance around the clock all year round. On top of this come personal and site protection and site-specific preparations, such as police stations and equipped security and civil defence centres; intelligence and information work and communication at home and abroad; and equipment for emergency teams in every state institution, around the clock, every day of the year. All of this requires constant vigilance and readiness, advanced logistical support, and costs that are difficult to estimate.
  5. International safeguards: The International Atomic Energy Agency applies a strict system to prevent nuclear materials and projects from being used for purposes other than those declared, such as military purposes, or in ways that could lead to unauthorised activity. A large project like this one is a matter of (great) sensitivity, not only because of the direct costs of the effort the state concerned commits to before the Agency, but also because of the costs of guarding against unforeseen or unexpected matters, which are many and complex and extend across the whole world, not only at the facility's site or within the country concerned.
  6. Rehabilitation of the sites of nuclear facilities and their annexes: The problem with large nuclear projects lies in the vast areas that will become unfit for use or for life. Large allocations are usually set aside for them from the project's revenues in the form of annual investments. However much is allocated, and whatever the effort and the precision of the measures taken, the sites of nuclear facilities remain a permanent source of danger, and many nuclear sites around the world are still abandoned decades after their closure. In Britain, for example, the government has set aside 7 billion dollars for rehabilitating nuclear power plant sites, yet the cost of rehabilitating a single nuclear site has so far reached nearly 15 billion pounds sterling; the work is still not finished, and the spending continues to bleed.

What makes the matter even more difficult is the extent to which investors, who seek quick profits at the lowest cost, will commit to bearing their responsibilities towards risks of this kind. And how can parties that invested in the project (and then withdrew for any reason or ended their investment) be held liable for the costs of hazards and risks that were unforeseen at the moment they withdrew, or that were not expected when the contracts were signed with them? Or for risks that were foreseen but then materialised, went out of control, and acquired a large and costly reach in space and time? Or for risks that were foreseen but whose effects extend for hundreds and thousands of years, such as pollution and the storage of radioactive waste underground?

It is thus clear that inferring a project's feasibility through a simple calculation, such as saying that we want to produce so many megawatts, which will cost us so many million dinars, and that we will sell them for so many million to make a profit of so many million, is a gross oversimplification of the feasibility approaches to large nuclear projects.

The matter is far bigger than simple calculations. Otherwise, we would find the whole world turned into countries exporting nuclear energy, and the nuclear programmes of major countries would not have been stalled or halted for decades.