Skip to content
Dr. Ali Al-Mur Encyclopedia
All Articles
Site Considerations by Dr. Ali Al-Mur

Approaches to Nuclear Energy

Published:
March 24, 2010
Reading time:
6 min read
Category:
Essay

Episode 6, "Site Considerations", examines the suitability of the announced project site and possible alternatives in light of the project's sensitivity, scale and requirements.

Published in Jordan's Al-Sabeel newspaper on 24 March 2010.

The most difficult aspect of nuclear projects is selecting the site on which the project will be built, especially for large energy facilities. Engineering designs are now well known and tested, materials have been proven, and securing fuel is no longer a difficulty. Site selection, however, is affected by dozens of sensitive variables that require a huge database and very complex computer programmes to analyse them and choose a suitable site, usually from among a set of available options. In short, there are no fixed criteria against which a place can be measured to determine whether it is suitable for the project, but rather general frameworks that must be followed in light of local variables and their sensitivities. These include considerations of health, security, public safety, environmental protection, economic and socio-economic factors, international relations, and so on. The following are some of the indicators that must be taken into account when selecting a site:

  1. Geological structure: The site of nuclear facilities must have a stable geological structure. Geological changes that may cause earthquakes must occur at long intervals, and the probability of any future earthquake must be assessed in relation to the project's design life. As an indicator, a nuclear facility must be at least 10 km from possible faults, or from geological formations 20 km long that are not classified as faults, and 50 km from areas of low seismic activity where earthquakes do not exceed 2–3 on the Richter scale. This condition is not met in the Aqaba area, which lies not only in the heart of a zone of secondary faults, but also at the great Quweira fault and at the junction of the Arabian and African plates. This junction witnessed one of the most violent tectonic plate movements, which caused a violent earthquake of magnitude 7.3 on the Richter scale. The area periodically experiences earthquakes of magnitude 6 every 30 years, as well as continuous seismic swarms of lower magnitude, such as the swarms of '83, '90, '93, '95, '96 and '98 in the last century. This has stimulated seismic activity on some secondary faults in the current decade and led to a swarm of earthquakes ranging from 1.5 to 3 on the Richter scale, the strongest of which reached 4.1 in 2007.
  2. Thermal pollution: Nuclear power plants generate large amounts of heat, which they release into the air and into the surrounding rivers and seas or those used to cool them. A plant must therefore be built far from closed and semi-closed bodies of water and from slow rivers in which the water exchange rate is less than 110 cubic metres per hour. Considering Aqaba a suitable site for the project on the grounds that it provides cooling water for the nuclear plant (as announced) is therefore an inaccurate assumption, if we avoid calling it a mistaken one, because the Gulf of Aqaba is a small, confined area and is considered semi-closed.
  3. Radioactive pollution: Nuclear power plants release large quantities of radioactive isotopes into the environment. One of the most important site considerations is therefore that the plant be far from sensitive and important places, such as current and planned residential communities; agricultural land, forests and woodland; areas designated for hunting and fishing; groundwater basins; airports and military bases; and mines and areas promising in natural resources. As an indicator, the plant must be no less than 2.5 kilometres from residential communities of fewer than 2,500 people, and no less than 5 kilometres from larger communities. As a general indicator, a population density of "zero people per square kilometre" within 50 kilometres of the plant is the ideal situation, while a density of 100 people per square kilometre within the same radius is a very poor choice!
  4. Topography and terrain: Aqaba (the city and the port) lies in a narrow, low-lying area surrounded by high mountains on almost three sides. This reduces the rate of air exchange and raises the concentration of radiation and radioactive dust emitted from the plant (if it is built), and it increases the severity of the thermal and radioactive pollution discussed in points (2) and (3).
  5. Climate: The prevailing (north-westerly) winds in Aqaba intensify the previous factor, as more dust is collected from the open northern areas where the plant would be built.
  6. Air eddies: The presence of an open body of water south of the city pushes the air eastwards, a few miles to the south. This traps the movement of the northerly winds, laden with desert dust and radioactive dust (if the plant is built), at a short distance south of Aqaba, creating an air eddy that concentrates desert and radioactive dust over the city.
  7. International borders: Nuclear facilities must be located at a calculated distance from international borders, for security reasons; to prevent transboundary radioactive releases, under the most severe possible normal operating conditions, from exceeding internationally permitted levels; and to give neighbouring countries enough time, in the event of accidents, to take the necessary protective measures, such as evacuation and relocation. This distance is agreed with neighbouring countries (as an indicator, 50 km is considered appropriate with the agreement of the parties concerned).
  8. Last but not least: We must pause carefully at the national particularities of Aqaba, which, despite its limited area, enjoys exceptional national importance in tourism, trade, the economy and population, now and even more so in the future. As Jordan's only sea outlet to the outside world, Aqaba must be preserved, and the type of projects built there must be planned for decades, and even longer. Otherwise, we will find it turned into a polluted site crowded with projects, activities and facilities, the worst of which are nuclear facilities. By then it will be too late, and not even the best dentists on earth will be able to make a set of teeth that restores to the "smiling seaport" its beauty and elegance!

Thus, all the considerations mentioned above, which are only a few of many, work against the "assumption" that the (hoped-for) Aqaba area is a suitable option for the (sought-after) nuclear plant, because each of them has, to put it mildly, a severe negative effect on the particularity and importance of the other... and on its beauty... (and its charm!).